Originally posted by Jos Maas:
AJ,
You will get a better result (playing Yamaha styles) if you replace your software XG module with a SW1000XG soundcard. But it would be much better if you created your own styles adapted to both your music and the (soft)synths you are using. You can rip some tracks from existing midifiles and styles and then add you personal magic. Use the stylemaker tools in OMB. That is the only way to get a better sound than the hardware arrangers. Somethings just aren't for sale.
Jos
I don't want the SWxg1000. Aside from what Frank stated, I have heard others lament about latency issues as well and the consensus is that the sounds are better than the SYXG50, but still not that good.
Maybe some things aren't for sale, but.. a complete arranger system that included it's own pallette of sounds that would rival any of the current hardware would be if I had the programming knowledge and talents that you have Jos. I can dig up and create good sounds and improve upon them in my synths, software or hardware, but I have little knowledge of computer based programming.
I'm already blown away by the analog modeling in the CS80V and Moog Modeler Frank. I've yet to hear anything comparable in the current crop of hardware analog modeling synths, although the Moog voyager and a couple of others have great sounds of their own. But... the cost and particularly the flexibility of the soft stuff vs the top end hardware modeling synths makes all the difference in the world to me.
Really, a soft arranger isn't all that big a deal to me anyway. As I have stated before, I use very little of what any arranger can give me to compose, except maybe as a starting point to compare and contrast backing vs melodies. These days, I think mostly in terms of live play when I think of using an arranger, and what I already have suits my needs just fine. It's the wonderful variety of sounds and "sculpting " tools available in soft versions that I look forward to using. Also, I plan on keeping the Motif ES ( it's a great tool ) and the PA80, so as Squeak points out, I'll have for me what is the best of both worlds. Thanks to all for sharing your thoughts.
AJ
[This message has been edited by Bluezplayer (edited 01-05-2004).]